MacGregor DNA Project

Where are we now? - Spring 2004

by Dr. Richard McGregor

This is the fourth update on the MacGregor DNA project. The number of participants in the project has now exceeded 100 – it currently stands at 104, although the number of active participants is in fact 89.

There has been a steady trickle of new members since the last update in September 2003 and at the time of writing this there are still a good number of test results outstanding.

Results (chart updated June 2004)
click on the chart for a close up view

In order to understand this update it is really necessary to follow through the previous ones as I have only labelled the newest test results on the phylogenetic trees of this update. I have adopted this approach simply for clarity, and to enable newer participants to determine how connected they are to the various branches. Rather than present the whole graphic, I have chosen this time to concentrate on the central group – virtually all of whom are from the Haplogroup R1b (once called Celtic, now properly referred to as Palaeolithic).

Chart 1

Chart 2

Chart 1 shows a simplified version (compared with charts in previous updates) of all the tests completed to date. To avoid cluttering up the chart I have only labelled those new results previously unplaced. It will be obvious however that the group of results around the MacGregor bloodline (the large yellow circle) is too dense to make out the detail.

Chart 2 therefore concentrates only on this section – which corresponds, more or less, to Haplogroup R1b found across Europe (Spain, France, North Italy, Germany and the Low Countries). Basically this is the result of expansion from an ancestral Y chromosome which developed during the last Ice Age in Iberia. Note that the Viking line on this chart goes off towards the top of the page rather than towards the bottom as in Chart 1, but otherwise is unaltered.

Chart 3

Chart 4

Chart 3 is a magnified version of Chart 2 focusing on those results which make up the MacGregor bloodline (elliptical shape labelled ‘Main’) and those tests results which might be directly connected but have more mutations than would be expected (Wider Group). New test results are given on this chart to enable participants to see where they lie. As in Chart 1 the main MacGregor bloodline is the largest yellow circle. Individual members of the project should contact me for clarification if required.

Chart 4 narrows the results down even further to concentrate only on the MacGregor bloodline and those most closely related. [All charts are derived from phylogenetic software from: www.fluxus-engineering.com]

Chart 5

Chart 6

Charts 5 and 6 are two new charts which look very much like a traditional family tree. It is important NOT to read these as ‘family trees’ which show ‘family’ connections. I have included two because careful examination will show that there are different ways of interpreting the genetic relationships. However the Viking and ‘recent Irish’ groups are still clearly grouped together. They are marked off by two parallel lines //. I have marked off the MacGregor bloodline group in the same way. I am reasonably confident that these three particular groups show common descent from 1) Gregor the name father of the clan (or his immediate forebears) for the MacGregor bloodline; 2) a common Irish ancestor within historic time for the Irish group; and 3) a common’ pre-Viking’ ancestor for the Viking group. All the individuals named Orr are related, but not to any of the last three groups, and various Grier and McAdam families are definitely related to each other but again not to any of the three lines above. There is evidence for separate origins for McAdam(s), one Irish and one probably not, and similarly for Grier (Greer), one Irish, one probably not. No other relationships are identifiable. On Charts 5 and 6 the kit number and surname is given. Remember these trees indicate genetic distance and we can be talking about thousands of years (that is, relating to colonisation following the last Ice Age).

The tree software uses ‘Phylip’ from http://evolution.genetics.washington.edu/phylip.html to generate the necessary grids, and the Tree Drawing software is from http://taxonomy.zoology.gla.ac.uk/rod/treeview.html.

Richard McGregor
Chairman Clan Gregor Society
DNA Project Coordinator

Back to the main DNA Page

DNA Webring

| HOME | DIRECTORY | NEWS | SOCIETY EVENTS | MEMBERSHIP | GENEALOGY | OUR TARTANS |
| LIBRARY | HISTORY | FAMOUS MACGREGORS | MESSAGE BOARD | PHOTO ALBUM
| CHILDREN OF THE MIST | KIDSTUFF | SOCIETY SHOP | WEBSITE SHOP | BOOKSHOP |
| FLOWERS OF THE FOREST | LINKS & AWARDS | CONTACTS |

This site designed by MacAle Designs ©2008
Updated 18 January, 2009